The bracket is now below. See post II for current entries and old songs.
Main Bracket
9. Lekunk 58 plays Mikey Is God (8/7) (12-4)
10. Bookshelf (bye) (8/11)
Second Chance Bracket
11. Porchball plays Badabing (8/8) (12-9)
12. Xwayne plays Iceagecoming (8/9) (11-7)
13. Jblagg plays Walter Sobchak (8/12) (9-2)
14. Margret Spread plays IC Light Years (8/10) (12-8)
Round V
15. Lekunk58 plays Bookshelf 8/30
16 Porchball plays Iceagecoming 8/28
17. Jblagg plays IC Light Years 8/29
18. Mikey Is God gets a bye
Round VI
19. Winner of 15 has a bye to the finals
20. Winner of 16 plays loser of 15
21. Winner of 17 plays 18
Round VII 22. Winner of 20 plays 21
Finals Winner of 22. vs. 19.
22 has to beat 19 twice.
Last edited by stip on Tue Aug 29, 2006 12:48 pm, edited 13 times in total.
_________________ "Better the occasional faults of a Government that lives in a spirit of charity than the consistent omissions of a Government frozen in the ice of its own indifference."--FDR
Joined: Tue Nov 30, 2004 4:02 am Posts: 44183 Location: New York Gender: Male
Lekunk---EXCELLENT reworking of the song. Your strongest song since long road, and possibly your best. I love the harmonica.
One of my favorite songs of the tournament.
Mikey--listening to you next.
Okay--yours was also quite good mikey (a good choice for you vocally and your guitar work is good as always), and had this been up against some of Lekunk's previous entries I would have given you the nod, but I was really blown away by his Red Mosquito.
_________________ "Better the occasional faults of a Government that lives in a spirit of charity than the consistent omissions of a Government frozen in the ice of its own indifference."--FDR
Post subject: Re: Pearl Jam Cover Battle: ROUND IV BEGINS
Posted: Mon Aug 07, 2006 1:24 pm
Unthought Known
Joined: Wed Aug 24, 2005 12:42 am Posts: 7939
stip wrote:
11. Porchball plays Badabing (8/8) 12. Xwayne plays Iceagecoming (8/9) 13. Jblagg plays Walter Sobchak (8/12) 14. Margret Spread plays IC Light Years (8/10)
I don't know these Pearl Jam songs.
_________________ I will pull your crooked teeth, you'll be toothless just like me
Last edited by Raziel on Mon Aug 07, 2006 3:58 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Joined: Tue May 30, 2006 2:48 pm Posts: 3115 Location: Edinburgh/Lincoln, UK
Red Mosquito was great It was clever and fun. i liked all the layers throughout..the harmonica touch, everything. I thought it was all really nicely worked out.
All or none was okay, but it was pretty uninteresting for me..just a kind of stripped down version of a song which relies on a great lead guitar and great vocal delivery to match, and i just don't think either were up to scratch. I think it's my favourite of your entries so far though.
Joined: Sun Apr 09, 2006 12:09 am Posts: 238 Location: granville OH/pittsburgh PA
both of these are awesome. i'm going with RM because of the unique interpretation and instrumentation. the harmonica sounds sweet, and is that a mandolin? amazing songs, both of you. i'm getting scared now...
Joined: Tue Apr 11, 2006 10:53 pm Posts: 21098 Location: where do you think?
wow what a way to come back from the break. you guys obviously worked very hard on these.
mikey - all or none was a faithfull reinterpretation, the acoustic sounds nice and boomy and you got a nice tone on the solos. captured the mood of the song quite well. awesome job.
lekunk - i really liked the reinterpretation here. from the slow, quiet building intro to the mandolin and harmonica work. and if i'm not mistaken the accordian makes another appearance? the mandolin sounds great. one of the best of the tournament so far.
after several listens, my vote goes to lekunk. good job to both.
it is indeed a mandolin. i must say, they are a pain in the ass to record since it gets out of tune after just a few strums. (at least mine does)
one interesting note- after i recorded this i showed it to a friend and he noted that the mandolin in the begining and the harmonica throughout the verses reminded him of a mosquito buzzing around his head. this lead me to slightly pan those tracks back and forth to highlight that. its much more noticible with headphones. Leave it to those intoxicated friends to give you your pointers
mikeyisgod- excellent job, also my favorite of your entries. recording was very crisp and the tone on the electric worked well. it is difficult to give McCready's solos justice so it left me wanting a bit more but overall, it was great
_________________ by rocket to the moon
by airplane to the rocket
by taxi to the airport
by front door to the taxi
by throwing down the blanket
hanging down the legs
-TMBG
no accordion in this one, sorry. I can see how you might be fooled. At times the harmonica in the background sounds similar, though, essentially, an accordion is just a giant harmonica...
_________________ by rocket to the moon
by airplane to the rocket
by taxi to the airport
by front door to the taxi
by throwing down the blanket
hanging down the legs
-TMBG
ok, mikeyisgod....i think you did an awesome job with all or none...the rythym guitar sounded amazing, and you pulled off singing in two octaves....i still think your voice could have used a bit more feeling...i know this isn't your song or anything, but you have to get into it....also, the lead guitar was a little redundant and i was waiting for the high notes but they never came....everything sounded great though
leknuk, that was a really cool rendition of RM....i like how you didn't carbon copy mike's lead guitar in that song (to be honest, i hate mike's part in that song)....you gave it an indie feel, and the mandolin sounded really cool...you were a little off timing with the vocals, but it sounded really cool....and by the way, the harmonica was bad ass...
Joined: Sat Apr 22, 2006 6:16 pm Posts: 645 Location: Chicago, IL
Hmmm...kind of struggled with both of these.
I REALLY liked the musical take on RM. Harmonica and guitar were sloppy seemingly on purpose and I dug that. Solos were nice and the separation from the standard version while not quite as far away as I originally perceived it to be, was still very cool...
However I had a very hard time with the consistent out of tune vocals esp. on the harmonies. Not sure if the dischord was purposeful or not...but it didn't sit well with me...
I liked the main guitar part on All or None a lot...the solos had good tone but seemed to lack the flow that makes them so beatuiful and haunting on the original and the vocals were consistently out of time and tune...
Of course these reviews are coming from the guy who had nothing to submit...
So I humbly bow to all of your collective prowess for having the talent and the balls above me to be here...
_________________ I surfaced and all of my being was enlightened.
Joined: Mon Mar 21, 2005 10:20 am Posts: 1178 Location: Hollywood, CA
just listened to RM, finally....uh..
yea, you kicked my ass. that was like 400% better than any other entry you did. i mean, you didn't even play it perfectly as per some of the criticisms made already but the ideas you presented (and they were still executed fairly well) pretty much did me in. i tried for the stripped down which i like but yea, you take this one easily. well done....you son of a bitch.
_________________ 09.13.98 Hartford, 04.11.03 West Palm Beach, 07.08.03 NYC, 07.09.03 NYC, 07.14.03 Holmdel, 10.01.04 Reading, 10.03.05 Philadelphia, 07.07.06 San Diego, 07.09.06 LA, 07.10.06 LA, 09.30.09 LA, 10.01.09 LA, 10.06.09 LA, 10.07.09 LA
ok, so singing is not my forte.... i'll stick to the strings. at least you all have the same critiques that i have of myself. i realize that one can always improve upon guitar/instrumental parts but singing is a hit or a miss.
mikeyisgod- dont be bitter, you will have the joy of watching my ass get handed to me next round
_________________ by rocket to the moon
by airplane to the rocket
by taxi to the airport
by front door to the taxi
by throwing down the blanket
hanging down the legs
-TMBG
Joined: Tue Nov 30, 2004 4:02 am Posts: 44183 Location: New York Gender: Male
I'm gonna call this one early since I don't think 8 more votes are coming in the next hour and a half and I won't be on-line at 9
Congrats Lekunk58 for advancing to the finals in the main bracket. Mikeyisgod moves to the second chance bracket
Final score 12-4
_________________ "Better the occasional faults of a Government that lives in a spirit of charity than the consistent omissions of a Government frozen in the ice of its own indifference."--FDR
Joined: Tue Nov 30, 2004 4:02 am Posts: 44183 Location: New York Gender: Male
Listening now
Nice job badabing. I've thought your entries were some of the most underrated of the entire tournamnet and this was a real nice soldier of love. You have one of the voices that can come closest to mimicking Eddie's and this one is no exception. I like the way you really have the bass propelling the song along too. Very enjoyable. Nicely done.
Porchball next...
Great version porchball. It reminds me a bit of booskhelf's happy when I'm crying in that I think I like yours more than the original (which I'm not a big fan of). Great tone on your guitar--it really captures the desolation in the song, and this is one of your better vocal performances. Probably your strongest entry since Angel.
I'm sorry to see Babdabing go if he loses, since I have a feeling I might like your soldier of love more than some of the other songs that might advance, but my vote goes to porchball
_________________ "Better the occasional faults of a Government that lives in a spirit of charity than the consistent omissions of a Government frozen in the ice of its own indifference."--FDR
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 5 guests
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot post attachments in this forum
It was clever and fun. i liked all the layers throughout..the harmonica touch, everything. I thought it was all really nicely worked out.
