If Evacuation's not "bad," the results of this experiment have to be questioned.
| Red Mosquito http://archive.theskyiscrape.com/ |
|
| Is there consensus?: Results thread http://archive.theskyiscrape.com/viewtopic.php?f=1&t=94707 |
Page 1 of 1 |
| Author: | stip [ Sat Apr 16, 2011 11:46 pm ] |
| Post subject: | Is there consensus?: Results thread |
Ten (good/great) Alive 23/23 (100%) Black 23/23 (100%) Porch 22/23 (96%) Release 22/23 (96%) Jeremy 22/23 (96%) Even Flow 21/23 (91%) Oceans 20/23 (87%) Once: 19/23 (83%) Why Go 18/23 (78%) Garden 15/23 (65%) Deep 12/23 (52%) Vs. (Good/Great) Go: 28/29 (97%) Rearview Mirror: 28/29 (97%) Animal: 27/29 (93%) Daughter: 27/29 (93%) Indifference: 27/29 (93%) Small Town: 26/29 (90%) W.M.A.: 23/29 (79%) Rats: 23/29 (79%) Blood : 20/29 (69%) Leash: 12/29 (41%) Dissident 11/29 (38%) Glorified G: 9/29 (31%) Vitalogy (Good/Great) Last Exit: 32/32 (100%) Not For You: 32/32 (100%) Corduroy: 32/32 (100%) Betterman: 32/32 (100%) Immortality: 32/32 (100%) Satan's Bed: 31/32 (97%) Tremor Christ: 30/32 (94%) Spin The Black Circle: 28/32 (88%) Nothingman: 28/32 (88%) Whipping: 28/32 (88%) Aye Davanita: 16/32 (50%) Bugs: 11/32 (34%) Pry, To: 5/32 (16%) Stupid Mop: 1/32 (3%) No Code (good/great) Hail Hail: 44/44 (100%) In My Tree: 44/44 (100%) Red Mosquito: 43/44 (98%) Present Tense: 42/44 (96%) Smile: 37/44 (84%) Who You Are: 35/44 (80%) Off He Goes: 35/44 (80%) Sometimes: 34/44 (77%) Around the Bend: 25/44 (57%) Habit: 20/44 (46%) Lukin: 20/44 (46%) Mankind: 9/44 (21%) I'm Open: 9/44 (21%) Yield (good/great) Do The Evolution: 34/34 (100%) Brain of J: 33/34 (97%) Faithful: 33/34 (97%) Given To Fly: 33/34 (97%) In Hiding: 32/34 (94%) All Those Yesterdays 32/34 (94%) Lowlight: 29/34 (85%) MFC: 28/34 (82%) Wishlist: 27/34 (79%) No Way: 26/34 (77%) Push Me/Pull Me: 20/34 (59%) Pilate: 13/24 (38%) Red Dot: 11/34 (32%) Hummus: 7/34 (21%) Binaural (good/great) Grievance: 38/39 (97%) Parting Ways: 37/39 (95%) Insignificance: 36/39(92%) Nothing As It Seems: 32/39 (82%) Of The Girl: 32/29 (82%) Rival: 32/39 (82%) Sleight of Hand: 31/39 (80%) Light Years: 28/39 (72%) Breakerfall: 21/39 (54%) Thin Air: 18/39 (46%) God's Dice: 16/39 (41%) Evacuation: 12/39 (31%) Soon Forget: 10/39 (26%) Riot Act (good/great) Can't Keep 34/35 (97%) I Am Mine 32/35 (91%) Save You 28/35 (80%) 1/2 Full 28/35 (80%) All Or None 25/35 (71%) Help Help 23/35 (66%) Cropduster 20/35 (57%) Green Disease 19/35 (54%) You Are 18/35 (51%) Love Boat Captain 14/35 (40%) Ghost 13/35 (37%) Thumbing My Way 11/35 (31%) Arc 10/35 (29%) Bushleaguer 9/35 (26%) Get Right 8/35 (23%) S/T (Good/Great) Comatose 30/39 (77%) Life Wasted 28/39 (72%) Severed Hand 27/39 (69%) World Wide Suicide 25/39 (64%) Parachutes 25/39% (64%) Marker In The Sand 24/39 (62%) Wasted Reprise 18/39 (46%) Unemployable 17/39 (44%) Army Reserve 17/39 (44%) Come Back 14/39 (36%) Big Wave 10/39 (26%) Inside Job 8/39 (21%) Gone 5/39 (13%) Backspacer (good/great) Got Some: 30/40 (75%) The End: 27/40 (68%) Johnny Guitar: 26/40 (65%) Just Breathe: 25/40 (63%) Unthought Known: 24/40 (60%) Gonna See My Friend: 21/40 (53%) Force of Nature: 17/40 (43%) The Fixer: 10/40 (25%) Speed of Sound: 9/40 (23%) Amongst The Waves 6/40 (15%) Supersonic 5/40 (13%) Okay, so this may be arbitrary, but I'd define consensus as being 75-100 thinking a song is good (it is) or 25-0 thinking it sucks. |
|
| Author: | stip [ Sun Apr 17, 2011 12:01 am ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Is there consensus?: Results thread |
So the albums would break down like this Ten Good/Great: 9 (once, even flow, alive, why go, black, jeremy, oceans, porch, release) Bad: 0 No consensus: 2 (garden, deep) Vs. Good/Great: 8 (go, animal, daughter, w.a.a., reaerviewmirror, rats, small town, indifference) Bad: 0 No consensus: 4 (glorified G, dissident, leash, blood) Vitalogy Good/Great: 10 (last exit, spin the black circle, not for you, tremor christ, nothingman, whipping, corduory, satan's bed, betterman, immortality) Bad: 2 pry to, stupid mop No consensus: 2 (bugs, aye davanita) No Code Good/Great: 8 (sometimes, hail hail, who you are, in my tree, smile, off he goes, red mosquito, present tense) Bad: 2 (mankind, i'm open) No consensus: 2 (habit, lukin, around the bend) Yield Good/Great: 10 (brain of j, faithful, no way, given to fly, wishlist, do the evolution, mfc, in hiding, lowlight, all those yesterdays) Bad: 1 (Hummus) No consensus: 3 (pilate, red dot, push me pull me) Binaural Good/Great: 7 (nothing as it seems, insignificance, of the girl, grievance, rival, sleight of hand, parting ways) Bad: 0 No consensus: 5 (light years, breakerfall, thin air, god's dice, evacuation, soon forget) Riot Act Good/great: 4 (can't keep, i am mine, save you, 1/2 full) Bad: 1 (get right) No consensus: 10 love boat captain, cropduster, ghost, thumbing my way, you are, green disease, help help, bushleaguer, arc, all or none) S/T Good/great: 1 (comatose) Bad: 2 (inside job, gone) No consensus: 10 (life wasted, world wide suicide, severed hand, marker in the sand, parachutes, unemployable, big wave, wasted reprise, army reserve, come back) Backspacer Good/great: 1 (got some) No consensus: 6 (gonna see my friend, johnny guitar, just breathe, unthought known, force of nature, the end) Bad: 4 (the fixer, amongst the waves, supersonic, speed of sound So it looks like people think almost everyone is good or great on everything up to Binaural. Once we have that 2 in front there's surprisingly little agreement. |
|
| Author: | AndySlash [ Sun Apr 17, 2011 12:12 am ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Is there consensus?: Results thread |
if one would have told me before this that only one song would be voted "good" on avocado, and that that song would be comatose, i'd have thought them a fool. |
|
| Author: | cutuphalfdead [ Sun Apr 17, 2011 3:03 am ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Is there consensus?: Results thread |
I'm still waiting for B to merge all the consensus threads into one big one. |
|
| Author: | bmacsmith [ Sun Apr 17, 2011 3:20 am ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Is there consensus?: Results thread |
nobody likes Yield? |
|
| Author: | Angus [ Sun Apr 17, 2011 3:06 pm ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Is there consensus?: Results thread |
cutuphalfdead wrote: I'm still waiting for B to merge all the consensus threads into one big one. Well, since we're going to have fuckers who missed out on the voting and will go bumping all these threads once a week, that might actually not be a bad idea. |
|
| Author: | CopperTom [ Sun Apr 17, 2011 10:10 pm ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Is there consensus?: Results thread |
If Evacuation's not "bad," the results of this experiment have to be questioned.
|
|
| Author: | cutuphalfdead [ Mon Apr 18, 2011 12:54 am ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Is there consensus?: Results thread |
CopperTom wrote: If Evacuation's not "bad," the results of this experiment have to be questioned. stfu |
|
| Author: | Spike [ Mon Apr 18, 2011 1:07 am ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Is there consensus?: Results thread |
i'm happy with these results as vitalogy and yield are their two best records. |
|
| Author: | Cameronia [ Mon Apr 18, 2011 5:06 am ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Is there consensus?: Results thread |
CopperTom wrote: If Evacuation's not "bad," the results of this experiment have to be questioned. Yeah, it means not enough dumbasses voted. |
|
| Page 1 of 1 | All times are UTC |
| Powered by phpBB © 2000, 2002, 2005, 2007 phpBB Group http://www.phpbb.com/ |
|