I remember when I was a kid I used to go to the grocery store and they had a wide selection of high quality VHS tapes. Anyways, I've got some of those VHS covers etched in my mind. Especially the ones we weren't allowed to see. One of them was a picture of a lady wearing silver makeup on her face. She's bent over a baby carriage, but she's looking at the "camera" and has her finger to her mouth doing the "shhhhh" gesture. I could have sworn it was "Rosemary's Baby" but I've searched the net for covers, and I've only come up with these 2 and pictures of Mia Farrow's tits.





Anyone have any idea what movie it was?

In case no one here is able to help you, write to the Onion AV Club. They have a whole section for stuff like this, if they haven't gotten rid of it. The worst I've ever seen them do was give a few possibilities and the person usually ends up finding what they were looking for. Check it out.

Man, I coulda sworn it was 'The Changeling' but after a quick GIS, no dice. Scary ass movie, though. At least it was when I was a kid.

If you found it at a grocery store, it'll be tought to track down. Those were usually black/grey market stuff done by companies who ofter did their own cover art for films, and sometimes had half a dozen different covers for single movies. My guess would be something from the It's Alive series:


The silver faced woman part reminds me of the cover for Blue Sunshine:


Are you sure you aren't mixing some covers together in your mind? That happens to me sometimes.

Alice Sweet Alice involved children (Brooke Shields, for one) and a silverish mask:


I don't know of any artwork with a baby carriage, though.

They stopped that segment unfortunately. (I think. I can't find it)

I should clarify they were movie rentals, so I think they were legitimate. You guys are close, but no dice. Ahh, it's going to drive me crazy

on a side note: here's a pic that is somewhat like what you described, from rosemary's baby,but not a cover or anything: