Joined: Sun Oct 17, 2004 1:56 am Posts: 386 Location: Chicago area
I'm going to have to go with the original studio recording with this one. Either the original or greatest hits re-mix. Best ever! It's the only song I could put on repeat forever and never get sick of. Now that's crazy!
Joined: Sun Oct 17, 2004 12:25 am Posts: 11849 Location: west coast
Angels Tribe wrote:
vedder10ua wrote:
i still don't see how peole can benaroya is a top version? ed mumbles over throughout the whole song, then he gets to the end and just lets the crowd sing it. the last minute or so is really cool, but the version as a whole is not good, IMO. the last minute or so of black is always good.
I'm really into Benaroya right now. The crowd really gets me.
am i the only one that hate the crowd singing the best part of the song?
_________________ I was unsure what to do; I'd never seen a girl choke on dick before. I thought that only happened in rap songs.
Joined: Sun Oct 17, 2004 6:23 pm Posts: 1144 Location: Richmond, VA Gender: Male
Stripe64 wrote:
Given2Fly2 wrote:
92 unplugged, though to top that
actually damn near impossible.
Eh, i think that version is a tad over rated, its awesome of course, but eddie messes up the first chorus, and i prefer the post 96 versions with mike wailing out for a few minutes at the end
_________________ Blessed are the forgetful, for they get the better even of their blunders.
-Nietzche
Eh, i think that version is a tad over rated, its awesome of course, but eddie messes up the first chorus, and i prefer the post 96 versions with mike wailing out for a few minutes at the end
He does????? You must be listening to a different version.
_________________ "The bigger the lie, the easier it is to believe." - Adolf Hitler
Joined: Sun Oct 17, 2004 6:23 pm Posts: 1144 Location: Richmond, VA Gender: Male
Stripe64 wrote:
HBK wrote:
Stripe64 wrote:
Given2Fly2 wrote:
92 unplugged, though to top that
actually damn near impossible.
Eh, i think that version is a tad over rated, its awesome of course, but eddie messes up the first chorus, and i prefer the post 96 versions with mike wailing out for a few minutes at the end
He does????? You must be listening to a different version.
This is what he messes up, he sings
"how quick the sun can, drop away
and now my bitter hands cradle broken glass"
instead of
"i know she gave me all that she wore"
a repeated part of the second chorus meaning...messed up first chorus.
It's right there on the video , check it out
a small nuance but still takes points off from me, but like i said, my big reason for thinking others are better is the wailing mike solo, something that truly shines when the song is done electrically
_________________ Blessed are the forgetful, for they get the better even of their blunders.
-Nietzche
Eh, i think that version is a tad over rated, its awesome of course, but eddie messes up the first chorus, and i prefer the post 96 versions with mike wailing out for a few minutes at the end
He does????? You must be listening to a different version.
This is what he messes up, he sings
"how quick the sun can, drop away and now my bitter hands cradle broken glass"
instead of
"i know she gave me all that she wore"
a repeated part of the second chorus meaning...messed up first chorus.
It's right there on the video , check it out
a small nuance but still takes points off from me, but like i said, my big reason for thinking others are better is the wailing mike solo, something that truly shines when the song is done electrically
I wouldn't consider this messing it up, he simply changed it, like he does with many songs in concert.
Messing up the song- A good example is Wishlist, July 11, 2003
_________________ "The bigger the lie, the easier it is to believe." - Adolf Hitler
Last edited by Bant on Sun Dec 05, 2004 10:04 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Joined: Wed Dec 08, 2004 2:46 pm Posts: 356 Location: London
lunkin wrote:
Angels Tribe wrote:
vedder10ua wrote:
i still don't see how peole can benaroya is a top version? ed mumbles over throughout the whole song, then he gets to the end and just lets the crowd sing it. the last minute or so is really cool, but the version as a whole is not good, IMO. the last minute or so of black is always good.
I'm really into Benaroya right now. The crowd really gets me.
am i the only one that hate the crowd singing the best part of the song?
yep
It gives me chills when I listen to that bit
It's my all time favourite song and when you actually see it live and everyone sings it's amazing, so to have a high quality version of it with crowd singing is what makes this version for me.
_________________ Some days your the pigeon and some days you're the statue....
Dublin, Verona, Milan, Prague, Berlin...see you there
Joined: Sun Oct 17, 2004 7:36 pm Posts: 3271 Location: Chicago
Stripe64 wrote:
HBK wrote:
Stripe64 wrote:
HBK wrote:
Stripe64 wrote:
Given2Fly2 wrote:
92 unplugged, though to top that
actually damn near impossible.
Eh, i think that version is a tad over rated, its awesome of course, but eddie messes up the first chorus, and i prefer the post 96 versions with mike wailing out for a few minutes at the end
He does????? You must be listening to a different version.
This is what he messes up, he sings
"how quick the sun can, drop away and now my bitter hands cradle broken glass"
instead of
"i know she gave me all that she wore"
a repeated part of the second chorus meaning...messed up first chorus.
It's right there on the video , check it out
a small nuance but still takes points off from me, but like i said, my big reason for thinking others are better is the wailing mike solo, something that truly shines when the song is done electrically
I wouldn't consider this messing it up, he simply changed it, like he does with many songs in concert.
Messing up the song- A good example is Wishlist, July 11, 2003
you can see eddie shaking his head after he sung it, so i would think he messed up, he didnt change the lyrics to something different, he used the same chorus twice instead of once.
_________________ strobe lights and blown speakers.
Joined: Sun Oct 17, 2004 6:23 pm Posts: 1144 Location: Richmond, VA Gender: Male
pnjguy wrote:
Stripe64 wrote:
HBK wrote:
Stripe64 wrote:
HBK wrote:
Stripe64 wrote:
Given2Fly2 wrote:
92 unplugged, though to top that
actually damn near impossible.
Eh, i think that version is a tad over rated, its awesome of course, but eddie messes up the first chorus, and i prefer the post 96 versions with mike wailing out for a few minutes at the end
He does????? You must be listening to a different version.
This is what he messes up, he sings
"how quick the sun can, drop away and now my bitter hands cradle broken glass"
instead of
"i know she gave me all that she wore"
a repeated part of the second chorus meaning...messed up first chorus.
It's right there on the video , check it out
a small nuance but still takes points off from me, but like i said, my big reason for thinking others are better is the wailing mike solo, something that truly shines when the song is done electrically
I wouldn't consider this messing it up, he simply changed it, like he does with many songs in concert.
Messing up the song- A good example is Wishlist, July 11, 2003
you can see eddie shaking his head after he sung it, so i would think he messed up, he didnt change the lyrics to something different, he used the same chorus twice instead of once.
Yeah...i would call it messing up to, since one would not normally change the first chorus of song by using different lyrics from the same song
_________________ Blessed are the forgetful, for they get the better even of their blunders.
-Nietzche
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 13 guests
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot post attachments in this forum
We belong together.
