im listening to it now... and wow.... its not so great. sure, there were 2 cat stevens covers (1 was the preset)... which rocks.... but the delivery pales in comparison to some of the shows from the same time frame.

and i was there... i just dont find the bootleg very interesting.

I totally adore the I believe in miracles - Light Years - Grievance - Sad - Given to fly run. That were like all favourites played in a row and I stil listen to them from very often. But yeah, the rest of the show... while it was amazing, it was still not near Kitchener's or Ottawa's level for example.

I find this show to be fantastic, both there and once I heard the boot. Not gonna find a much better version of grievance. The band was on fire. I thought this night was better than ottawa.

I started to think about this (should do that more often before I post)

Light Years
Miracles
Betterman/I wanna be your boyfriend

those are a few of my total Canada trip highlights.

Montreal was superb! Need to listen to it again.

I love light years, betterman, trouble, in my tree, etc. from this show, i think it's better than ottawa too

the only show that topped ottawa was maybe philly. maybe. montreal is really good, but not better.

Ottawa was long, was incredibly good, but after seeing them I only ranked it third behind Hamilton & Kitchener.

Oh well.

This show rocked. The Save You and Blood were very tight and the Harvest Moon was beautiful (even W/ SK).
Those were my highlights

Halifax topped them all

I agree.

i think ottawa and specially philly are overrated, at least from what i listen on the boots

Yup

fuck yeah

not convinced? need some visual proof? then check this out ..

http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid ... =pearl+jam

Wrong Wrong Wrong......

Kitchener was the best of the "Your a Hoser" Shows in 05...and Yes Philly 05 was overated, I was there.


Grand Rapids was the best show so far of 2006 followed closely by San Diego.

I disagree I was at both shows, ottawa was not nearly peformed half as good as montreal was. I have listened to ALOT of shows. Montreal has some of the best versions of the whole canadian tour. People think setlist = great show. but it is not always true.

example

Cleveland 06 is fucking sick, no one even says a word cause the setlist is so-so.

i listened to the first set today, and i somewhat take my statement back. i think i was just undewhelmed by black and crazy mary.

the grievance is a great version.

Light Years Grievance Sad is awesome. PLUS Blood Black Baba. Montreal is a very good show.

Philly is not overrated, just a few too many covers.

Yeah, the best show on the tour, Philly, was overrated.

Canadian envy again.

Philly is a good show, but it isn't flawless, while no show is. Montreal was just pure raw energy through the first whole set. I love the philly show. But montreal is one of the most overlooked shows of that tour.

Just because the Montreal show is overlooked doesn't mean Philly is overrated.