Every year the music magazines bore us with what they believe to be the top "whatever" of "whatever" and every year they never cease to amaze me with their shittiness. I for one can't stand year end lists. So i propose we post all the crappy lists in all their half assed glory here and hopefully come up with a TOP 10 SHITTY LISTS OF 2004!!!!

Heres my 2 picks culled from recent threads. As the new year approaches im certain there will dozens more to add:

List: 50 Best Cover Versions Ever Named
Offending Publication: XFM
Link: http://www.xfm.co.uk/Article.asp?id=55694&page=2

List: Top 500 Songs of all Time
Offending Publication: Rolling Stone
Link: http://www.rollingstone.com/news/story/_/id/6596661/sort/rank/pagenum/1

every list ever made gets my vote.

IMO no matter how great one person thinks a list is another will think it sucks, so no list is really the be all end all. i just read lists for fun, and dont bother taken them serious cause what i think is great on whatever list another person prolly thinks shouldnt be there

http://www.digitaldreamdoor.com (go to music list on the left) It's not the worst, it's the best out there, i'm sure some of yall will agree with me


Those lists you posted are pretty terrible, especially the Rolling Stone top 500 songs

I dont think its possible to be satisfied with any list unless you wrote it yourself because its just opinion

so yes any list that claims to be definitive is crap

thanks for the link. theyve got some interesting lists there. maybe there is some hope out there.