The 13-track Wind-Up CD has cuts from Seether's three studio albums, including "Remedy" (a 2005 No. 1 entry on Billboard's Mainstream Rock chart), a new mix of "The Gift" and a cover of Pearl Jam's "Immortality," the original of which peaked at No. 10 on the Mainstream Rock tally in 1995.


of all the songs..immortality! that's the golden nugget these guys have smeared.


theyre going straight to music-hell.

I hope I never have to hear that.

I don't see the problem. The dude can sing but I don't care for their music at all. Maybe they do a good job.

no i know im being a bit melo-dramatic here


but of all the songs to pick...immortality? geez. that's one of pj's holy grails for me

See what I'm saying? They pick inmortality instead of I got shit!!! Why everybody hates that song?

i dont get this thread, but im against said blasphemy.

Even if I don't like the artist covering PJ I don't have a problem with it. Whether it be Seether, Staind, or Mariah Carey. They are showing respect for Pearl Jam and their music. What's wrong with that?

I don't like the band that much, actually like the song "the gift" i heard the other day on the radio, but picking a great one like Immortality gives them some cred in my book. The main problem is that it's another nu-grunge band that hasn't taken their love for their influences and done anything new with that love but almost copied them.

I will not be listening to this. (Well, maybe just once out of curiosity).

seether is okay. nothing extraordinairy. but obviously they were fans of the same type of music that most of us here adore. i like to cover songs of my favorite bands. me and my boys just happen to not do it all too well and we're not signed to a record label....so nobody cares if we play all the PJ or nirvana we want.......


let em do the song. maybe people will be like "wow thats a cool song...wonder who wrote that"

always curious to hear pj covers by other artists. I liked the black cover by arron lewis of staind

Nah.....its ok. They arent ruining that song. That song is amazing and if someone wants to cover it, its a compliment. I didnt like the dude from that one band's cover of Black, but the gesture was nice.

A couple of things...

1. Who is Seether? They sound like a band that would be on my local station that plays Metallica all of the time.




I would like Mariah Carey to cover me.


*cough*

I'll be here all week, don't forget to tip your waiter.







Seriously, I am going to be a stand-up comedian.

Seether was a hit for Veruca Salt. That's all I've got.

I hear the DJ talk about them on the X in Pittsburgh, but have never listened long enough to hear them. Normally though, the X doesnt play anyone who totally sucks.

I think it is cool any time somebody covers PJ.

Me too...and I am always super curious to listen to it... at least once.

I'm curious to hear it. I could see them doing reasonable justice to a PJ song, although I don't know if I'd have picked immortality

The first time I heard remedy I thought the guy sounded exactly like Kurt Cobain in the verses.

dont like seether at all, but id be curious to hear it

what does seether sound like-the name sounds familiar i just cant thnk of what they sound like... for some reason im thinking their heavy