Joined: Thu Nov 25, 2004 7:23 am Posts: 51 Location: Walking the cow
what are you talking about, that was the best version since the first time mike and eddie did it...
_________________ theft and hoarding of wealth at the expense and disregard of the livelihood and wellbeing of the masses will result in a complete and total loss of compassion for any other living being and will blacken your heart
Joined: Sun Oct 17, 2004 1:42 am Posts: 11014 Location: Mizzou Gender: Male
duszynski6 wrote:
what are you talking about, that was the best version since the first time mike and eddie did it...
It wasn't as bad as people are saying it was. I still think the Bridge School version and any VFC version is better, especially the VFC finale version which I consider to be the best.
_________________ "Red rover, red rover, let Mike McCready take over."
Joined: Wed Nov 03, 2004 11:23 pm Posts: 6165 Location: Mass
StyrofoamChicken wrote:
There's really no reason for Eddie to be playing guitar on this.
this is true, in fact this is true on several songs.
Actually, if you watch real close, sometimes eddie will play a bar or two up at the 14th fret (that's an octave up from open Em) so he is doing something different.
My theory on the sub par quality of this performance is that they had just played two absolutely rockin shows in Beantown and were headed to Reading. Reading was incredible, so my guess is that they just had an off night in a craptacular place to play music. Even our boys are allowed a mulligan every now and again. That being said I still enjoyed watching them on TV last night. It caught me by suprise which is always nice.
My $.02
_________________ and i listen for the voice inside my head, nothing, i'll do this one myself
Joined: Tue Oct 19, 2004 4:05 am Posts: 11 Location: Melbourne, Australia
My husband woke me up at 2.45 in the morning to see them on tv. Of course I got up to watch it, even though I'd seen it before. I always like seeing the boys on tv, repeat or not. I dont think it was a bad performance at all.
_________________ Pearl Jam are my drug of addiction!
I'm just wondering if you guys were watching the same performance I did.
I think this version is second only to the Bobfest original. There is a slow burn happening here that is really powerful and an intensity, not only to the vocal, but to the buildup of dynamics of the band sound at key moments in the song that blew me away.
btw, as far as Ed on guitar, his part is what adds the tension to the mix that makes this version so powerful.
The Bobfest version was all about full out anger. This new version and even the way it was edited on Letterman was a direct, concentrated reaction to the times and couldn't be more appropriate, dealing with all the aspects in question: the war mongers, the religious right and the greed that prompted this latest war.
I may never have been more proud to be a fan of this band than I was on the night this first aired.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 28 guests
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot post attachments in this forum
