Joined: Sun Nov 21, 2004 12:39 am Posts: 9940 Location: This heart of mine
Now so many people completely make nothing of Bonds hitting 714 because of the roid, and nearly all other HR makrs nowadays. But why are actual game results never disregarded as such? We know roids are in the game, but we have no way of knowing exactly who is doing what, but clearly there is an advantage somewhere in there. Why aren't the WS champions of the last 10 years completely disregarded like all these home run totals?
Joined: Sun Oct 17, 2004 12:47 am Posts: 46000 Location: Reasonville
Where's The Old Board? wrote:
Now so many people completely make nothing of Bonds hitting 714 because of the roid, and nearly all other HR makrs nowadays. But why are actual game results never disregarded as such? We know roids are in the game, but we have no way of knowing exactly who is doing what, but clearly there is an advantage somewhere in there. Why aren't the WS champions of the last 10 years completely disregarded like all these home run totals?
good point. barry's giants got in vs. the angels a few years back, for example.
_________________ No matter how dark the storm gets overhead They say someone's watching from the calm at the edge What about us when we're down here in it? We gotta watch our backs
Joined: Fri Sep 02, 2005 6:02 am Posts: 173 Gender: Male
Where's The Old Board? wrote:
Why aren't the WS champions of the last 10 years completely disregarded like all these home run totals?
Maybe it's because I'm a huge White Sox fan, but I'm pretty sure none of the players on last year's team were on 'roids. Their offense was predicated on laying down bunts, stealing, and the hit and run. Sure they had some power with Konerko and Dye (and now Thome), but this is a team that goes out and plays good fundamental baseball.
Why aren't the WS champions of the last 10 years completely disregarded like all these home run totals?
Maybe it's because I'm a huge White Sox fan, but I'm pretty sure none of the players on last year's team were on 'roids. Their offense was predicated on laying down bunts, stealing, and the hit and run. Sure they had some power with Konerko and Dye (and now Thome), but this is a team that goes out and plays good fundamental baseball.
this is a load of bullshit fed to the public by ozzie guillen. the white sox hit 200 home runs last year, fifth in the league. they were 16th in the league in sacrifice hits. they stole a lot, but that was skewed by the presence of podsednik. and anyway, since they were 22nd in the league in stolen base percentage at 67% it's virtually impossible stealing bases added to the team's run total through the course of the season.
thing is, the white sox weren't that good of an offensive team, and if they didn't have massive amounts of power last year they'd have been the pirates. but they had excellent starting pitching and some really aberrational performances from otherwise bad pitchers like dustin hermanson and cliff politte that put the team over the hump. this crap they relied on bunts and small ball is just mumbo jumbo.
Joined: Sun Oct 17, 2004 3:08 am Posts: 22978 Gender: Male
Where's The Old Board? wrote:
Now so many people completely make nothing of Bonds hitting 714 because of the roid, and nearly all other HR makrs nowadays. But why are actual game results never disregarded as such? We know roids are in the game, but we have no way of knowing exactly who is doing what, but clearly there is an advantage somewhere in there. Why aren't the WS champions of the last 10 years completely disregarded like all these home run totals?
Honestly? I think its based on an assumption that all the teams had a couple guys on roids... it balanced on a team level to some extent.
Now so many people completely make nothing of Bonds hitting 714 because of the roid, and nearly all other HR makrs nowadays. But why are actual game results never disregarded as such? We know roids are in the game, but we have no way of knowing exactly who is doing what, but clearly there is an advantage somewhere in there. Why aren't the WS champions of the last 10 years completely disregarded like all these home run totals?
Honestly? I think its based on an assumption that all the teams had a couple guys on roids... it balanced on a team level to some extent.
exactly. Unless MLB is able to go back in time and figure out exactly what hitters and pitchers were using steroids, it's pointless to dispute W-L records and outcomes of specific games IMO.
_________________ “You’re good kids, stay together. Trust each other and be good teammates to one another. I believe there is a championship in this room.”
-Ernie Accorsi in his final address to the NY Giants locker room before retiring as GM in January of 2007
Why aren't the WS champions of the last 10 years completely disregarded like all these home run totals?
Maybe it's because I'm a huge White Sox fan, but I'm pretty sure none of the players on last year's team were on 'roids. Their offense was predicated on laying down bunts, stealing, and the hit and run. Sure they had some power with Konerko and Dye (and now Thome), but this is a team that goes out and plays good fundamental baseball.
this is a load of bullshit fed to the public by ozzie guillen. the white sox hit 200 home runs last year, fifth in the league. they were 16th in the league in sacrifice hits. they stole a lot, but that was skewed by the presence of podsednik. and anyway, since they were 22nd in the league in stolen base percentage at 67% it's virtually impossible stealing bases added to the team's run total through the course of the season.
thing is, the white sox weren't that good of an offensive team, and if they didn't have massive amounts of power last year they'd have been the pirates. but they had excellent starting pitching and some really aberrational performances from otherwise bad pitchers like dustin hermanson and cliff politte that put the team over the hump. this crap they relied on bunts and small ball is just mumbo jumbo.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 17 guests
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot post attachments in this forum
