Filling mine out now... whod you go with?

AL

C
1B
2B
3B
SS
OF
OF
OF


NL

C
1B
2B
3B
SS
OF
OF
OF

AL

1B: Konerko.
Hafner and Ortiz barely play in the field, they don't count.

2B: Jose Lopez
His average has dipped, but his power numbers and RBI crush all other players

SS: Tejada
Jeter is having a great year, but Miggy's HR numbers are impossible to ignore.

3B: ARod
No one is setting themselves as the front runner in this category. Throw 5 guys in a hat and pick one.

C: Mauer
.380! Seriously, there's no competition here.

OF: Vernon Wells, Carl Crawford, Alexis Rios (write in)
I don't like Ichiro because all he does is slap singles and steal meaningless bases. The 3 I chose are all having great all-around seasons.


NL

1B: Lance Berkman
Obviously, I would vote for Pujols if he was available.

2B: Dan Uggla
Having a remarkable rookie season out of nowhere.

SS: Edgar Renteria
The NL SS is awful this year.

3B: David Wright
This is the toughest position to pick. Cabrera, Rolen, and Wright?

C: Brian McCann
At least the Braves have him this year.

OF: Jason Bay, Carlos Lee, Alfonso Soriano
I'm not picking any Rockies, no way.

I can only remember the Dodgers I voted for, which were Nomar 1B, Russ Martin C (write in), Matt Kemp OF (write in) and Jeff Kent 2B (god knows why, he blows this year).

also David Wright 3B

I voted Victor

AL

C Teddy Bruschi
1B Teddy Bruschi
2B Teddy Bruschi
3B Teddy Bruschi
SS Ditka
OF Teddy Bruschi
OF Teddy Bruschi
OF Teddy Bruschi


NL

C Teddy Bruschi
1B Albert Pujols
2B Teddy Bruschi
3B Teddy Bruschi
SS Teddy Bruschi
OF Teddy Bruschi
OF Teddy Bruschi
OF Teddy Bruschi

I'll have to do this. Definately Crawford. He's having an amazing year. I wouldn't be suprised to see multiple D-Rays this year. Kazmir should be there as a backup pitcher.

AL

1B - Anyone from the Yankees/Red Sox
2B - Anyone from the Yankees/Red Sox
3B - Anyone from the Yankees/Red Sox
SS - Anyone from the Yankees/Red Sox
C - Anyone from the Yankees/Red Sox
LF - Anyone from the Yankees/Red Sox
CF - Anyone from the Yankees/Red Sox
RF - Anyone from the Yankees/Red Sox

AT fan balloting is a joke.

WTF are you talking about?

thank you! why in the hell he's like 12th in AL catchers is beyond me!

Most fans vote based on name, not performance.

Which is why a guy like Posada will start ahead of a guy like Mauer.

AL

C Joe Mauer
1B Mark Teixiera
2B Robinson Cano
3B Eric Chavez
SS Derek Jeter
OF Carl Crawford
OF Vernon Wells
OF Nick Swisher


NL

C Micheal Barrett
1B Albert Pujols
2B Jose Vidro
3B Scott Rolen
SS David Eckstein
OF Alfonso Soriano
OF Jason Bay
OF Carlos Beltran

hasn't Teixiera been having problems hitting HRs?

He's having a terrible season. .279/6/38. Terrible choice, sorry. He's the worst infielder on his own team right now.

I voted for Barrett just for that punch of Pierzynski.

are people voting for Pujols NOW or did you vote for him before his injury?

voting for him NOW knowing there is ZERO chance he will play the game is why fans voting for the starters is bullshit

NL

C Michael Barrett
1B Ryan Howard (he is slumping but you can't ignore his numbers)
2B Chase Utley
SS Jose Reyes
3B Scott Rolen
OF Jason Bay
OF Alfonso Soriano
OF Carlos Lee

AL

C Joe Mauer
1B Jason Giambi
2B Jose Lopez
SS Miguel Tejada
3B Alex Rodriguez
OF Vernon Wells
OF Jermaine Dye
OF Carl Crawford
DH Jim Thome

............Avg. HR RBI OBP Slug. Errors

Player A .316 7 37 .364 .514 4
Player B .285 15 50 .395 .514 11


Who do you choose?

well we know who YOU would choose...

Who would YOU choose?