Red Mosquito • View topic - RM's Top 10 Quaterbacks of All-time (List Revealed)

Too Big a Man Too Say · **Posted:** Tue Feb 06, 2007 7:43 pm

RM's Top 10 Quarterbacks of All-time

10. Roger Staubach - 31 points, 9/17 ballots (3)*
- Dallas Cowboys (1969-1979)
- 4 Super Bowl appearances, 2 Wins
- 22,700 yards, 57.0%, 153 tds, 109 int, 83.4 Rating

9. Terry Bradshaw - 37 points, 9/17 ballots (4)
- Pittsburgh Steelers (1970-1983)
- 4 Super Bowl appearances, 4 wins
- 27,989 yards, 51.9%. 212 tds, 210 int, 70.9 Rating

8. Tom Brady - 57 points, 11/17 ballots (4)
- New England Patriots (2000- )
- 3 Super Bowl appearances. 3 wins
- 21,564 yards, 61.9%, 147 tds, 78 int, 88.4 Rating

7. Brett Favre - 64 points, 12/17 ballots (2)
- Atlanta Falcons (1991) Green Bay Packers (1992- )
- 2 Super Bowl appearances, 1 win
- 57,500 yards, 61.1%, 414 tds, 273 int, 85.0 Rating

6. Steve Young - 76 points, 12/17 ballots (1)
- Tampa Bay Bucaneers (1985-1986) San Francisco 49ers (1987
-1999)
- 1 Super Bowl appearance, 1 win (as starter)
- 33.124 yards, 64.3%. 232 tds, 107 int, 96.8 Rating

5. Peyton Manning - 81 points, 14/17 ballots (2)
- Indianapolis Colts (1998- )
- 1 Super Bowl appearance, 1 win
- 37.586 yards, 64.0 %, 275 tds, 139 int, 94.4 Rating

4. Johnny Unitas - 104 points, 16/17 ballots (1)
- Baltimore Colts (1956-1972) San Diego Chargers (1973)
- 2 NFL Championships, 2 Super Bowl appearances, 1 win
- 40,239 yards, 54.6%, 290 tds, 253 int, 78.2 Rating

3. John Elway - 111 points, 17/17 ballots (1)
- Denver Broncos (1983-1998)
- 5 Super Bowl appearances, 2 wins
- 51,475 yards, 56.9%, 300 tds, 226 int, 79.9 Rating

2. Dan Marino - 122 points, 17/17 ballots (1)
- Miami Dolphins (1983-1999)
- 1 Super Bowl appearance
- 61,361 yards, 59.4%, 420 tds, 252 int, 86.4 Rating

1. Joe Montana - 143 points, 17/17 ballots (1)
- San Francisco 49ers (1979-1992) Kansas City Chiefs (1993-1994)
- 4 Super Bowl appearances, 4 wins
- 40,551 yards, 63.2%, 273 tds, 139 int, 92.3 Rating

*Number in parenthesis is the highest rank player received.

Also Receiving Votes:
Sammy Baugh - 23 points, 5/17 ballots
Bart Starr - 23 points, 6/17 ballots
Troy Aikman - 14 points, 7/17 ballots
Fran Tarkenton - 14 points, 6/17 ballots
Dan Fouts - 12 points, 4/17 ballots
Warren Moon - 8 points, 4/17 ballots
Joe Namath - 7 points, 1/17 ballots
Otto Graham - 5 points, 1/17 ballots
Jim Kelly - 2 points, 1/17 ballots
Donovan McNabb - 1 point, 1/17 ballots

warehouse · **Posted:** Tue Feb 06, 2007 7:45 pm

jeff garcia

and id say top 5

Peter Van Wieren · **Joined:** Sun Oct 17, 2004 4:31 pm **Posts:** 7610

I think I already did mine in the other thread, but why PM and not post? Feeling lonely?

Koufax · **Posted:** Tue Feb 06, 2007 7:50 pm

TJ Rubley
Tony Banks
Chris Miller
Jim Everett
Jamie Martin

I win

EllisEamos · **Posted:** Tue Feb 06, 2007 8:01 pm

Peter Van Wieren wrote:

but why PM and not post?

i'd rather just have them be posted, more debate that way, or just have a poll made of the top 50 and we'll narrow it down.

pearljamfan80 · **Posted:** Tue Feb 06, 2007 8:33 pm

top 10. then PM Lists, just like all the other lists.

And if Sammy Baugh doesn't make the list it's a crock of shit.

Too Big a Man Too Say · **Posted:** Tue Feb 06, 2007 8:45 pm

Peter Van Wieren wrote:

I think I already did mine in the other thread, but why PM and not post? Feeling lonely?

I think if they are posted in the thread it will sway other people's rankings.

Clubber · **Posted:** Tue Feb 06, 2007 10:33 pm

I like the PM list. We can debate afterwards. Sent mine already and people are gonna hammer me for it

holierthanthou · **Joined:** Tue Dec 06, 2005 5:48 am **Posts:** 2859

i PM'd mine already.

But If Tom Brady does not get the best this is a joke. the guy is unreal.

warehouse · **Posted:** Tue Feb 06, 2007 10:34 pm

Clubber wrote:

I like the PM list. We can debate afterwards. Sent mine already and people are gonna hammer me for it

im putting manning #1 too

Clubber · **Posted:** Tue Feb 06, 2007 10:37 pm

warehouse wrote:

Clubber wrote:

I like the PM list. We can debate afterwards. Sent mine already and people are gonna hammer me for it

im putting manning #1 too

haha! I actually didn't put Manning #1 but still pretty high.

Koufax · **Posted:** Tue Feb 06, 2007 10:39 pm

holierthanthou wrote:

i PM'd mine already.

But If Tom Brady does not get the best this is a joke. the guy is unreal.

he is so far from the top its laughable. no where near the top.

insignificant10 · **Posted:** Tue Feb 06, 2007 10:40 pm

Koufax wrote:

TJ Rubley
Tony Banks
Chris Miller
Chris Everett
Jamie Martin

I win

Koufax · **Posted:** Tue Feb 06, 2007 10:41 pm

insignificant10 wrote:

Koufax wrote:

TJ Rubley
Tony Banks
Chris Miller
Chris Everett
Jamie Martin

I win

hey, you want a beat down like Rome got????????

EllisEamos · **Posted:** Tue Feb 06, 2007 10:41 pm

Koufax wrote:

holierthanthou wrote:

i PM'd mine already.

But If Tom Brady does not get the best this is a joke. the guy is unreal.

he is so far from the top its laughable. no where near the top.

I love the guy, but he's not number 1.

warehouse · **Posted:** Tue Feb 06, 2007 10:43 pm

Koufax wrote:

holierthanthou wrote:

i PM'd mine already.

But If Tom Brady does not get the best this is a joke. the guy is unreal.

he is so far from the top its laughable. no where near the top.

top 5? if peyton is in the conversation brady has to be

Ricardo Tubbs · **Joined:** Thu Dec 02, 2004 6:08 pm **Posts:** 8255

holierthanthou wrote:

i PM'd mine already.

But If Tom Brady does not get the best this is a joke. the guy is unreal.

are you aware the NFL existed before the 2001?

i got bugs · **Joined:** Sun Oct 17, 2004 5:01 pm **Posts:** 14261

holierthanthou wrote:

i PM'd mine already.

But If Tom Brady does not get the best this is a joke. the guy is unreal.

no bernie kosar at #1?

Koufax · **Posted:** Tue Feb 06, 2007 10:48 pm

warehouse wrote:

Koufax wrote:

holierthanthou wrote:

i PM'd mine already.

But If Tom Brady does not get the best this is a joke. the guy is unreal.

he is so far from the top its laughable. no where near the top.

top 5? if peyton is in the conversation brady has to be

I dont think sobut then again I hate the guy like he killed my mother.

Brady is a great QB, which kills me to say, but top 5? He just doesnt impress me. yes his team wins a lot, but he had an amazing TEAM around him, from the line, to the defense, to the coaching staff. I mean, how many guys in history have played on such a complete team where it was next to impossible to find flaws?

and now that hes starting to lose some of his coaches and some of the guys hes won SBs with, hes not doing as well. I think I even read him say himself that he wasnt comfortable yet with all the turnover on that team. I just dont see him as one of the greatest of all times, even if he winds up with the most rings out of all of them.

Too Big a Man Too Say · **Posted:** Tue Feb 06, 2007 11:09 pm

So far of the rankings i've gotten half have been top 5 and half have been top 10. I think we need to be in agreement about how many we are ranking. Personally, i dont think top 10 is too far of a stretch.
But it doesnt really matter to me, let me know what you all think

RM's Top 10 Quaterbacks of All-time (List Revealed)

Who is online