Joined: Mon Oct 18, 2004 11:02 pm Posts: 569 Location: Yorba Linda, CA
I originally created a topic like this during the summer. I think it's a little more exciting than just posting the albums in order. Either way, it's a great way to waste 10 minutes if you're bored.
If anyone wants to participate, it's up to you if you choose to put the more experimental tracks on your list. I tend to stick to straight songs.
And just because a song is at the end of a list, doesn't mean it's bad-- to give a better idea of what songs I like and the ones I don't, I'll put a line at the point where I begin to not particularly like them.
1)Better Man
2)Corduroy
3)Nothingman
4)Immortality
5)Whipping
6)Last Exit
7)Satan's Bed
Not For You
9)Spin The Black Circle
10)Tremor Christ
No Code
1)Hail Hail
2)Red Mosquito
3)Present Tense
4)Off He Goes
5)Habit
6)Lukin
7)In My Tree(This one is really on the border)
-----------------
Who You Are
9)Smile
10)Around The Bend
11)Sometimes
Yield
1)In Hiding
2)Low Light
3)Brain Of J
4)Faithfull
5)MFC
6)Given To Fly
7)Do The Evolution
-------------------------
Wishlist
9)No Way
10)All Those Yesterdays
11)Pilate
Binaural
1)Light Years
2)Gods' Dice
3)Nothing As It Seems
4)Grievance
5)Thin Air
6)Of The Girl
7)Insignificance
Sleight Of Hand
9)Breakerfall
10)Evacuation (Really grown on me)
---------------------------------------------
11)Rival
12)Parting Ways
13)Soon Forget
Riot Act
1)Love Boat Captain
2)All Or None
3)I Am Mine
4)Can't Keep (Used to hate it, now I really like it)
5)Save You
6)Ghost
7)Cropduster
You Are
9)Thumbing My Way
10)Green Disease
11)1/2 Full (Barely makes the cut-- the outro saves the song)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
12)Bu$hleaguer
13)Get Right
14)Help Help
There you go. I'm not going to do Lost Dogs or any B-Sides.
Joined: Mon Dec 06, 2004 1:30 pm Posts: 918 Location: Miami Gender: Male
TEN
Oceans
Jeremy
Porch
Release
Black
Deep
Even Flow
Once
Garden
Why Go
Alive
VS.
Rats
RVM
Elderly
Indifference
Blood
Go
Leash
W.M.A.
Animal
Daughter
Glorified G
--
Dissident
VITALOGY
Satan's Bed
Last Exit
Bugs
Whipping
Immortality
Not For You
Tremor Christ
STBC
Corduroy
Stupid Mop
Betterman
Aye Davanita
Pry, To
NO CODE
Hail, Hail
Habit
Present Tense
In My Tree
Who You Are
Sometimes
Off He Goes
Lukin
Around The Bend
Smile
Red Mosquito
I'm Open
Mankind
YIELD
Brain of J.
DTE
Given to Fly
MFC
Faithful
Push Me, Pull Me
In Hiding
No Way
Red Dot
Pilate
All Those Yesterdays
--
Low Light
BINAURAL
Grievance
Of the Girl
Sleight of Hand
Light Years
Soon Forget
Insignificance
Evacuation
NAIS
Parting Ways
Thin Air
Breakerfall
Rival
God's Dice
RIOT ACT
Can't Keep
Green Disease
You Are
1/2 Full
All or None
Arc
LBC
Save You
I Am Mine
Bu$leaguer
Cropduster
Ghost
Get Right
TMW
Help, Help
LOST DOGS 1
Undone
All Night
Sad
YL
Alone
Down
Education
U
Black, Red, Yellow
Leaving Here
Whale Song
Hold On
Gremmie
Hitchhiker
In the Moonlight
Don't Gimme No Lip
LOST DOGS 2
4/20/02
Hard To Imagine
Dirty Frank
Brother
Dead Man
Bee Girl
Last Kiss
Footsteps
Wash
Drifting
Let Me Sleep
Fatal
Otherside
Strangest Tribe
--
Sweet Lew
OTHERS
Out of My Mind
Saying No
Angel
Girl
Untitled
Olympic Platinum
_________________
Angus wrote:
Sleater-Kinney is a gift from God to mankind. Then that gift was taken away again because mankind was too stupid to realize how kind God was to give mankind such beautiful present.
Joined: Sat Oct 16, 2004 11:08 pm Posts: 232 Location: w. seattle Gender: Female
ten
black
porch
jeremy
why go
alive
release
once
oceans
garden
deep
even flow
vs
rearview mirror
daughter
go
animal
small town
indifference
blood
dissident
wma
leash
glorified g
rats
vitalogy
corduroy
spin the black circle
last exit
better man
not for you
nothingman
immortality
tremor christ
satans bed
bugs
whipping
pry to
aye davanita
stupid mop
no code
off he goes
in my tree
lukin
around the bend
present tense
hail hail
smile
red mosquito
who you are
habit
sometimes
mankind
im open
yield
in hiding
brain of j
do the evolution
mfc
lowlight
given to fly
faithfull
no way
push me pull me
all those yesterdays
pilate
wishlist
color red
binaural
breakerfall
parting ways
light years
grievance
insignificance
sleight of hand
soon forget
gods dice
thin air
nothing as it seems
of the girl
rival
evacuation
riot act
you are
green disease
love boat captain
can't keep
all or none
ghost
save you
i am mine
cropduster
thumbing my way
get right
help help
half full
arc
bushleaguer
Ive got about 20 mins before class...ill give it a shot.
TEN
Black
Oceans
Garden
Alive
Release
Porch
Deep
Once
Jeremy
Even Flow
----
Why Go
VS
Small Town
Rearviewmirror
Indifference
WMA (this song has grown on me in recent months)
Leash
Glorified G
Animal
Rats
Dissident
Daughter
Go
----
Blood
VITALOGY (EP)
Immortality
Tremor Christ
Satan's Bed
Nothingman
Corduroy
Not For You
Betterman
--------
Spin the Black Circle
Aye Davanita
Last Exit
Bugs
Pry to
Whipping
Stupid Mop
NO CODE
Present Tense
Hail, Hail
Red Mosquito
Smile
In My Tree
Off He Goes
Who You Are
I'm Open
Around the Bend
----
Sometimes
Lukin
Habit
YIELD
No Way
Do the Evolution
Given to Fly
Lowlight
In Hiding
Faithfull
MFC
Brain of J
Push Me Pull Me
All those Yesterdays
------
Wishlist
Pilate
The Color Red
BINAURAL
Grievance
Light Years
Parting Ways
Insignificance
Of the Girl
Sleight of Hand
Rival
Soon Forget
Breakerfall
Nothing As it Seems
-------
Thin Air
Evacuation
Gods' Dice
RIOT ACT
1/2 Full
Love Boat Captain
All or None
Thumbing My Way
Can't Keep
I am Mine
Green Disease
Bushleaguer
Arc
You Are
----
Save You
Get Right
Ghost
Help, Help
Cropduster
LOST DOGS
Sad
Hold On
Undone
YLB
Leaving Here
Education
Down
Alone
Black Red Yellow
Whale Song
Dont Gimme No Lip
Gremmie Out of Control
All Night
----
In the Moonlight
Hitchiker
U
Hard to Imagine
Fatal
Otherside
Strangest Tribe
Footsteps
Driftin
Dead Man
Let Me Sleep
Dirty Frank
Brother
Wash
Last Kiss
Bee Girl
Sweet Lew
Did this by song recently.....so I inlcuded it with 10 being best songs:
10
Of The Girl
Corduroy
Hail Hail
Sad
I Am Mine
Given to Fly
Even Flow
State of Love and Trust
In Hiding
I Got Shit
Elderly Woman Behind the Counter in a Small Town
Better Man
Do the Evolution
Breath
Rearviewmirror
Crazy Mary
Alive
Yellow Ledbetter
9
Long Road
Go
Animal
Save You
Brain of J.
Down
Nothingman
Porch
Jeremy
Black
Low Light
Footsteps
Release
8
Can't Keep
In My Tree
Grievance
Spin The Black Circle
Gods' Dice
Fatal
Once
U
Get Right
Hold On
Smile
Dead Man
Immortality
7
W.M.A.
Dissident
Not For You
All Night
Love Boat Captain
Green Disease
Daughter
Man of The Hour
Present Tense
MFC
Who You Are
Insignificance
Leatherman
Why Go
Undone
Light Years
Indifference
Leaving Here
6
Oceans
Ghost
Breakerfall
Glorified G
Pilate
Cropduster
1/2 Full
Education
Lukin
Wishlist
Evacuation
Thumbing My Way
Hard to Imagine
Whipping
Blood
Driftin
Off He Goes
5
Arc
Thin Air
Alone
No Way
Red Mosquito
Habit
Black, Red and Yellow
Don’t Gimme No Lip
Nothing As It Seems
Rival
Last Kiss
You Are
Satan's Bed
Otherside
All Or None
Last Exit
4
Sometimes
Wash
Deep
In The Moonlight
Leash
Garden
Sleight Of Hand
I'm Open
Around the Bend
Gremmie Out of Control
Soon Forget
Bushleaguer
Parting Ways
Angel
Let Me Sleep
3
Red Dot
Tremor Christ
Faithful
Hitchhiker
Whale Song
Mankind
Dirty Frank
Push Me Pull Me
Sweet Lew
Rats
Bee Girl
Soldier of Love
Help, Help
Strangest Tribe
All Those Yesterdays
My Ranks Based on These Scores
1. Ten 8.1
2. Yield 7.6
3. Vs. 7.2
5. Vitalogy 7.1
4. Riot Act 6.9
6. Binaural 6.8
7. No Code 6.6
Joined: Sun Oct 17, 2004 7:19 pm Posts: 39068 Location: Chapel Hill, NC, USA Gender: Male
Alright, this took me like an hour. I smashed Lost Dogs and a bunch of other shit into the albums I thought they went best with to make 7 uber-albums. I figured if I was reduxing ... I might as well fucking redux.
Ten (1991)
Release
Porch
Dirty Frank
Oceans
Yellow Ledbetter
State of Love and Trust
Evenflow
Alive
Once
Footsteps
Breath
Wash
Garden
Black
Girl
Jeremy
Deep
Brother
Why Go
Let Me Sleep
Alone
I’ve Got A Feeling
Vs. (1993)
Indifference
Leash
Rats
Crazy Mary
Angel
Elderly Woman
Hold On
Blood
Animal
Daughter
Hard To Imagine
Dissident
Go
Rearviewmirror
Sonic Reducer
Glorified G
Bee Girl
WMA
Vitalogy (1994)
Pry, To
Immortality
Bugs
Satan’s Bed
Nothingman
Spin The Black Circle
Tremor Christ
Whipping
Last Exit
Aye Davanita
Not For You
Corduroy
Hey Foxymophandlemama, That’s Me
Betterman
No Code (1996)
RED MOSQUITO (I love this damn board!)
Smile
I Got Id
Around The Bend
Long Road
Gremmie Out of Control
All Night
In My Tree
Off He Goes
Lukin
Present Tense
Lukin (What the hell, it’s short!)
Face of Love
Leavin’ Here
Sometimes
Black Red Yellow
Deadman
Habit
I’m Open
Don’t Gimme No Lip
Hail, Hail
Who You Are
Mankind
Yield (1998)
The Color Red
All Those Yesterdays
Low Light
Do The Evolution
Given To Fly
Wishlist
Faithfull
U
MFC
Happy When I’m Smiling
No Way
Pilate
Push Me, Pull Me
In Hiding
Olympic Platinum
Leatherman
Brain of J
Binaural (2000)
Parting Ways
Drifting
Rival
In The Moonlight
Education
Of The Girl
Thin Air
Nothing As It Seems
Sleight of Hand
Soon Forget
Sad
Fatal
Strangest Tribe
Insignificance
Sweet Lew
Soldier of Love
Hitchhiker
Grievance
Evacuation
Light Years
Last Kiss
Whale Song
Gods’ Dice
Breakerfall
Riot Act (2002)
Arc
All or None
Man of the Hour
Down
LBC (Molo Edition)
Foldback
Thumbing My Way
I Am Mine
Other Side
Undone
½ Full
Thunderclap
You Are
Bu$hleaguer
Save You
I’m Still Here
Can’t Keep
Green Disease
Get Right
I Just Want Something To Do
Help Help
Cropduster
Ghost
Harmony
_________________ "Though some may think there should be a separation between art/music and politics, it should be reinforced that art can be a form of nonviolent protest." - e.v.
Joined: Sun Oct 17, 2004 3:45 pm Posts: 257 Location: New York
this my ranking as for right now but im sure they will change by tomorrow morning.
ten:
1. release
2. deep
3. alive
4. black
5. porch
6. oceans
7. once
8. even flow
9. why go
10. garden
11. jeremy
vs
1. rats
2. leash
3. RVM
4. glorified g
5. blood
6 indifference
7. animal
8. small town
9. dissident
10. daughter
11. wma
12. go
vitalogy
1. betterman
2. not for you
3. tremor christ
4. STBC
5. corduroy
6. satans bed
7. last exit
8. nothingman
9. whipping
10. immortality
11. bugs
12. pry, to
13. aye davinta
14. Hey Foxymophandlemama, That's Me
no code
1. in my tree
2. res mosquito
3. smile
4. hail, hail
5. present tense
6. sometimes
7. habit
8. who you are
9. lukin
10. off he goes
12. im open
13. around the bend
yield
1. all those yesterdays
2. do the evolution
3. given to fly
4. faithful
5. no way
6. mfc
7. brain of j
8. in hiding
9. wishlist
10 pilate
11. low light
12. push me, pull me
13. the color red
binaural
1. rival
2 grievance
3 breakerfall
4 evacuation
5 parting ways
6 gods dice
7 light years
8 NAIS
9 of the girl
10 soon forget
11 insignificance
12 sleight of hand
13 thin air
riot act
1 LBC
2 save you
3 green disease
4 i am mine
5 ghost
6 cant keep
7 help help
8 arc
9 1/2 full
10 bushleauger
11 cropduster
12 get right
13 you are
14 all or none
15 thumbing my way
this was really hard because seriously i think i love every song equally as crazy as that might sound even tough i do love some songs more than others i love every song and i hate ranking them like this. .
Joined: Tue Nov 30, 2004 4:02 am Posts: 44183 Location: New York Gender: Male
Bump---I missed the first time around. Some of the other posts seemed to miss the point of the thread though
Ten Alive
Even Flow
Porch
Release
Black
Why Go
Once
Oceans
Deep
Garden
Vs Indifference
Small Town
RVM
Animal
Go
Leash
Rats
WMA
Blood
Glorified G
Dissident (used to be one of my favorites)
Daughter
Vitalogy Corduroy
Betterman
Immortality
Nothingman
Last Exit
Tremor Christ
Satan's Bed
Not For You
Whipping
STBC
No Code Red Mosquito
Present Tense
In My Tree
Smile
Hail Hail
Who You Are
Sometimes
Habit
Lukin
I'm Open
Around the bend
off he goes
mankind
Yield Do the evolution
Given to fly
Brain of J
Wishlist
All those yesterdays
Faithful
In Hiding
MFC
No Way
Push/Pull
Pilate
Lowlight
Binaural Grievance
Insignificance
Light Years
Parting Ways
Breakerfall
NAIS
Rival
Of a girl
Sleight of hand
Evacuation
soon forget
god's dice
thin air
Riot Act (this one is the hardest for me to do)
I Am Mine
Save You
Can't Keep
you are
1/2 full
all or none
Ghost
Thumbing My Way
Love Boat Captain
get right
green disease
help help
Cropduster
bushleaguer
_________________ "Better the occasional faults of a Government that lives in a spirit of charity than the consistent omissions of a Government frozen in the ice of its own indifference."--FDR
Post subject: Re: Rank the songs on each album Redux
Posted: Thu Mar 23, 2006 2:32 am
Unthought Known
Joined: Sun Oct 17, 2004 12:05 am Posts: 8045 Location: Arlington Heights, IL Gender: Male
rohfe100 wrote:
I originally created a topic like this during the summer. I think it's a little more exciting than just posting the albums in order. Either way, it's a great way to waste 10 minutes if you're bored.
If anyone wants to participate, it's up to you if you choose to put the more experimental tracks on your list. I tend to stick to straight songs.
And just because a song is at the end of a list, doesn't mean it's bad-- to give a better idea of what songs I like and the ones I don't, I'll put a line at the point where I begin to not particularly like them.
1)Better Man 2)Corduroy 3)Nothingman 4)Immortality 5)Whipping 6)Last Exit 7)Satan's Bed Not For You 9)Spin The Black Circle 10)Tremor Christ
No Code
1)Hail Hail 2)Red Mosquito 3)Present Tense 4)Off He Goes 5)Habit 6)Lukin 7)In My Tree(This one is really on the border) ----------------- Who You Are 9)Smile 10)Around The Bend 11)Sometimes
Yield
1)In Hiding 2)Low Light 3)Brain Of J 4)Faithfull 5)MFC 6)Given To Fly 7)Do The Evolution ------------------------- Wishlist 9)No Way 10)All Those Yesterdays 11)Pilate
Binaural
1)Light Years 2)Gods' Dice 3)Nothing As It Seems 4)Grievance 5)Thin Air 6)Of The Girl 7)Insignificance Sleight Of Hand 9)Breakerfall 10)Evacuation (Really grown on me) --------------------------------------------- 11)Rival 12)Parting Ways 13)Soon Forget
Riot Act
1)Love Boat Captain 2)All Or None 3)I Am Mine 4)Can't Keep (Used to hate it, now I really like it) 5)Save You 6)Ghost 7)Cropduster You Are 9)Thumbing My Way 10)Green Disease 11)1/2 Full (Barely makes the cut-- the outro saves the song) ------------------------------------------------------------------------ 12)Bu$hleaguer 13)Get Right 14)Help Help
There you go. I'm not going to do Lost Dogs or any B-Sides.
no offense, but you have a very strange taste in songs. no who you are, no way, parting ways, all those yesterdays, sometimes, smile and garden? those are all in my top 30-40
Joined: Sat Dec 04, 2004 5:41 am Posts: 255 Location: south florida
Ten
Release
Porch
Oceans
Jeremy
Black
Once
Alive
Garden
Deep
Why Go
Evenflow
Vs
RVM
Daughter
Blood
Small Town
Animal
Go
Indifference
Dissident
WMA
Rats
Glorified
Leash
Vitalogy
Corduroy
Immortality
Last Exit
Not for You
Satan's Bed
Betterman
Tremor Christ
Nothingman
Whipping
STBC
No Code
Off he Goes
Hail Hail
In My Tree
Red Mosquito
Lukin
Present Tense
Smile
Who You Are
Sometimes
Around the Bend
Habit
I'm Open
Mankind
Yield
Given to fly
Do the evolution
Brain of J
MFC
All those yesterdays
Lowlight
In Hiding
Faithful
No Way
Wishlist
Pilate
Push Pull
Binaural
Insignificance
Rival
Of the Girl (live)
Sleight of Hand (live)
Grievance
Parting Ways
NAIS
Evacuation
Thin air
Breakherfall
Light Years
Gods Dice
Soon Forget
Riot Act
I Am Mine
Save You
All or None
1/2 full
you are (live)
Cant Keep
Ghost
LBC
Green Disease
Cropduster
Help Help (live)
Get Right
Bushleaguer
Thumbing My Way
Joined: Tue Nov 30, 2004 4:02 am Posts: 44183 Location: New York Gender: Male
Kalevi wrote:
Ten
Release Porch Oceans Jeremy Black Once Alive Garden Deep Why Go Evenflow
I always get sad when I see even flow at the bottom of ten.
_________________ "Better the occasional faults of a Government that lives in a spirit of charity than the consistent omissions of a Government frozen in the ice of its own indifference."--FDR
Joined: Sun Dec 05, 2004 5:47 am Posts: 27904 Location: Philadelphia Gender: Male
Kalevi wrote:
Riot Act
I Am Mine Save You All or None 1/2 full you are (live) Cant Keep Ghost LBC Green Disease Cropduster Help Help (live) Get Right Bushleaguer Thumbing My Way
Damn you TMW haters to hell!!
_________________ It's always the fallen ones who think they're always gonna save me.
Joined: Wed Nov 03, 2004 4:20 pm Posts: 3649 Location: Scottsdale, AZ
Damn, this is going to be tough, but here's my rankings:
TEN
Alive
Black
Oceans
Jeremy
Garden
Release
Even Flow
Once
Porch
Deep
Why Go
VS
Rearviewmirror
Animal
Daughter
Indifference
Dissident
Elderly Woman Behind the Counter in a Small Town
Go
Leash
Rats
Glorified G
Blood
WMA
VITALOGY
Better Man
Corduroy
Not For You
Immortality
Nothingman
Tremor Christ
Last Exit
Whipping
Spin the Black Circle
Satan's Bed
Aye Davanita/Pry, To/Bugs/Hey Foxymophandlemama, That's Me
NO CODE
Present Tense
Hail, Hail
In My Tree
Red Mosquito
Smile
Who You Are
Off He Goes
Habit
Around the Bend
Lukin
Mankind
Sometimes
I'm Open
YIELD
Faithful
In Hiding
Brain of J
All Those Yesterdays
Do the Evolution
Given to Fly
MFC
Low Light
Wishlist
No Way
Pilate
Push Me, Pull Me
[Red Dot]
BINAURAL
Light Years
Breakerfall
Nothing as it Seems
Thin Air
Insignificance
Grievance
Gods' Dice
Of the Girl
Rival
Parting Ways
Evacuation
Sleight of Hand
Soon Forget
RIOT ACT
All Or None
Love Boat Captain
Save You
1/2 Full
You Are
I Am Mine
Cropduster
Ghost
Green Disease
Thumbing My Way
Get Right
Can't Keep
Bu$hleaguer
Help, Help
Arc
_________________ "And in the end, the love you take is equal to the love you make."
Joined: Tue Nov 30, 2004 4:02 am Posts: 44183 Location: New York Gender: Male
whygodeep wrote:
Damn, this is going to be tough, but here's my rankings:
TEN
Alive Black Oceans Jeremy Garden Release Even Flow Once Porch Deep Why Go
so your name is whygodeep, and they're your bottom two songs on Ten?
_________________ "Better the occasional faults of a Government that lives in a spirit of charity than the consistent omissions of a Government frozen in the ice of its own indifference."--FDR
Joined: Wed Nov 03, 2004 4:20 pm Posts: 3649 Location: Scottsdale, AZ
stip wrote:
whygodeep wrote:
Damn, this is going to be tough, but here's my rankings:
TEN
Alive Black Oceans Jeremy Garden Release Even Flow Once Porch Deep Why Go
so your name is whygodeep, and they're your bottom two songs on Ten?
I didn't even notice that. But even if they are the botton 2 songs, I'd still give them about a 7/10; there's nothing bad about them, but they don't rank up their with "alive" or "black"
_________________ "And in the end, the love you take is equal to the love you make."
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 3 guests
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot post attachments in this forum
Once
I didn't even notice that. But even if they are the botton 2 songs, I'd still give them about a 7/10; there's nothing bad about them, but they don't rank up their with "alive" or "black"