Joined: Thu Nov 25, 2004 3:00 pm Posts: 19826 Location: Alone in a corridor
I have a question about this show.
Sorry if it's 'too personal', but I'll just have a go at it:
This is a truly amazing shows. One of my favourites I've ever heard of Pearl Jam. But who is 'John'? Is it someone who died shortly before the concert or what?
During Release: "Oh dear John, can you see me now?"
Before Given to fly he talks about it being about someone who isn't amongst us anymore. And his emotions during Given to fly are so strong.
During Last Kiss he's also changing some of the lyrics.
(yes, this is the Speaking as someone who pahked the cah at the gahden - quarter rant show)
Joined: Sun Oct 17, 2004 6:38 pm Posts: 2055 Location: lurking
Angus wrote:
I have a question about this show. Sorry if it's 'too personal', but I'll just have a go at it:
This is a truly amazing shows. One of my favourites I've ever heard of Pearl Jam. But who is 'John'? Is it someone who died shortly before the concert or what?
During Release: "Oh dear John, can you see me now?" Before Given to fly he talks about it being about someone who isn't amongst us anymore. And his emotions during Given to fly are so strong. During Last Kiss he's also changing some of the lyrics.
(yes, this is the Speaking as someone who pahked the cah at the gahden - quarter rant show)
Joined: Mon Oct 18, 2004 1:04 am Posts: 660 Location: vancouver, wa Gender: Male
from what i remember reading online, eddie was given a letter at somepoint between the first and second nights. it was from the sister, whose brother had recently died. i have no idea if this is true or not though.
sorry i cant give you more help. great show though, it will always be one of my favorite's that i've been too.
Joined: Sun Oct 17, 2004 12:05 am Posts: 8045 Location: Arlington Heights, IL Gender: Male
RrrrrrredBelly wrote:
from what i remember reading online, eddie was given a letter at somepoint between the first and second nights. it was from the sister, whose brother had recently died. i have no idea if this is true or not though.
sorry i cant give you more help. great show though, it will always be one of my favorite's that i've been too.
During Last Kiss, he changes the lyrics to "Oh where could my brother be, the lord took him away from me". So that may be it?
Joined: Sun Oct 17, 2004 1:40 pm Posts: 439 Location: Massachusetts Gender: Male
RrrrrrredBelly wrote:
from what i remember reading online, eddie was given a letter at somepoint between the first and second nights. it was from the sister, whose brother had recently died. i have no idea if this is true or not though.
sorry i cant give you more help. great show though, it will always be one of my favorite's that i've been too.
i have herd that story. never read it anywhere though. thats very interesting. if you remember where you read that, i would love to see it. Some one told me this story while i was at a college party at North Adams State. Just some random dude i started chatting with about pJ cause of his PJ shirt. We got to talking about bootlegs and shows when this one came up. He told the story like he knew the person that wrote the letters. I didnt totally believe him at the time, but the story always stuck with me.
the "john" references are abundant during the VFC shows too. eddie dedicated a bunch of songs to johnny ramone and put his name in a few songs too (release at boston 04 #1, man of the hour boston 04#2)
Joined: Mon Oct 18, 2004 1:04 am Posts: 660 Location: vancouver, wa Gender: Male
JeromeTurner5 wrote:
RrrrrrredBelly wrote:
from what i remember reading online, eddie was given a letter at somepoint between the first and second nights. it was from the sister, whose brother had recently died. i have no idea if this is true or not though.
sorry i cant give you more help. great show though, it will always be one of my favorite's that i've been too.
i have herd that story. never read it anywhere though. thats very interesting. if you remember where you read that, i would love to see it. Some one told me this story while i was at a college party at North Adams State. Just some random dude i started chatting with about pJ cause of his PJ shirt. We got to talking about bootlegs and shows when this one came up. He told the story like he knew the person that wrote the letters. I didnt totally believe him at the time, but the story always stuck with me.
it was just in one of the online forums, so its very possible that it was a made up story, although from what eddie says during the show, it could have some truth to it.
Joined: Sun Oct 17, 2004 1:40 pm Posts: 439 Location: Massachusetts Gender: Male
RrrrrrredBelly wrote:
JeromeTurner5 wrote:
RrrrrrredBelly wrote:
from what i remember reading online, eddie was given a letter at somepoint between the first and second nights. it was from the sister, whose brother had recently died. i have no idea if this is true or not though.
sorry i cant give you more help. great show though, it will always be one of my favorite's that i've been too.
i have herd that story. never read it anywhere though. thats very interesting. if you remember where you read that, i would love to see it. Some one told me this story while i was at a college party at North Adams State. Just some random dude i started chatting with about pJ cause of his PJ shirt. We got to talking about bootlegs and shows when this one came up. He told the story like he knew the person that wrote the letters. I didnt totally believe him at the time, but the story always stuck with me.
it was just in one of the online forums, so its very possible that it was a made up story, although from what eddie says during the show, it could have some truth to it.
well this was like three months after the show, so hearing theis from another person, I believe it now. I dont thik he was an internet person way back then.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 20 guests
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot post attachments in this forum
pearljamlive.com it should be up on there.